Click Here to Install Silverlight*
United StatesChange|All Microsoft Sites
Microsoft Media and Entertainment
|Hosting Providers Home

Software + Services Marketing Best Practices

Key Success Factor: Scorecard

Grade Yourself with the Key Success Factors Scorecard

Use the scorecard below to assess your business against the 8 Key Success Factors and determine where you should focus your energy to improve your hosting fitness score.

  Level 1 Ineffective Level 2 Inhibited Level 3 Predictable Level 4 Competitive Level 5 Optimized
Competitive Differentiation
Messaging & Positioning
Packaging & Pricing
Web Driven Business
Demand Generation
Online Customer Experience
Direct & Indirect Sales
Organizational Effectiveness

Your Scorecard:

Below is a summary and description of your self-evaluation. Print this page for reference.

Competitive Differentiation
Level 1

Provider is offering the exact same service offering as other providers (perhaps based on third-party technologies) with no opportunity for true differentiation, resulting in a Red Ocean in which the only remaining competetive differentiator is price.

Competitive Differentiation
Level 2

Provider's offering is functionally equivalent to that of other providers, resulting in a "my feature X beats your feature X" competitive differentiation tactic, but ultimately resulting in a price-competitive sale.

Competitive Differentiation
Level 3

Provider has differentiated from the competition by bundling additional services or capabilities not offered by the competition.

Competitive Differentiation
Level 4

Provider has differentiated with a vertical market focus with vertical (or micro-market) specific add-on capabilities/features.

Competitive Differentiation
Level 5

Provider has differentiated with a vertical market focus with vertical (or micro-market) specific add-on capabilities/features.

Messaging & Positioning
Level 1

Positioning is completely product and feature centric. Positioning is effective only for customers who already know what they need and are already familiar with the specific application domain.

Messaging & Positioning
Level 2

Still product and feature centric positioning with progress towards customer-centric benefits positioning. Typically a lack of consistent application of messaging across all channels and collateral.

Messaging & Positioning
Level 3

Customer centric positioning with Benefits (e.g. Anytime, Anywhere access), then supporting benefits points, then features as appropriate. Consistent application of messaging throughout ALL collateral.

Messaging & Positioning
Level 4

Best Practice positioning based on a well-defined messaging & position framework (see template). Customer centric positioning that blends customer-benefit as the solution for the customer pain point/problem.

Messaging & Positioning
Level 5

Vertical (e.g. Real Estate), Horizontal specialization (e.g. Finance), or other micro-market specific positioning. User focus groups or surveys are pro-actively used to incorporate customer feedback into product life-cycle.

Packaging & Pricing
Level 1

Typically characterized by uncompetitive pricing, minimum contract terms, minimum # of users, confusing pricing, too many tiers of service, multiple tiers instead of "add-on" options.

Packaging & Pricing
Level 2

Competitive pricing and correct packaging, but actively working to eliminate other inhibitors (e.g. contract minimums).

Packaging & Pricing
Level 3

Small number (2-3) of different customer/user "plans" that align correctly with end-user or customer personas. Value differentiation between different price plans is clear and significant.

Packaging & Pricing
Level 4

Some type of unique differentiation of packaging or pricing that sets the provider apart of the reset of the pack.

Packaging & Pricing
Level 5

Micro-market specific packaging/bundling of service with vertically focused add-ons. Market research used to understand customer price-point sensitivities.

Web Driven Business
Level 1

Customers are unable to find offering, presentation is confusing, no online self-subscription is available.

Web Driven Business
Level 2

Customers can search, find, and buy. Provider is actively working to ensure that all of the information required to make a successful buying decision is on the site and correctly presented, eliminating any final inhibitors to selling.

Web Driven Business
Level 3

Best-practice site that allows customers to 1) Search; 2) Find; 3) Self Qualify; 4) Try (Free Trial where possible); 5) Make the buying decision; 6) Buy; 7) Activate. Web-site is the focal point of the business.

Web Driven Business
Level 4

Differentiated sub-sites and/or landing pages aligned with best-practice positioning of value proposition according to messaging & positioning framework

Web Driven Business
Level 5

Micro-market sales sites for specific vertical markets (e.g. real-estate). Fully integrated PPC/SEO and pro-active analysis of web-analytics

Demand Generation
Level 1

No PPC/SEO campaigns. Other demand generation activities (e.g. Print ads, direct mail, etc) do not leverage the web-site.

Demand Generation
Level 2

PPC/SEO and other demand generation capabilities are leveraged, but with some inhibiting factors that limit their effectiveness (e.g. mismatch between PPC terms and landing page positioning). Active progress is being made to eliminate remaining inhibitors.

Demand Generation
Level 3

Makes use of pro-active PPC/SEO campaigns. All demand generation activities lead to one place -- the web-site.

Demand Generation
Level 4

Demand generation campaigns drive to a specific sub-site or landing page. All campaign activities are well coordinated and integrated. Pro-active PPC/SEO campaign management with periodic (e.g. bi-weekly) refinement.

Demand Generation
Level 5

Micro-market specific demand generation campaigns with integration across all forms of demand generation (e.g. PPC, Banner Ads, email, direct mail, print)

Online Customer Experience
Level 1

No self-signup capability, direct sales interaction required. No offering self-administration.

Online Customer Experience
Level 2

Self-guided signup, support, and/or self-administration but inhibited in some way -- e.g. overly complex registration process, complex activation. Active progress is being made to eliminate remaining inhibitors.

Online Customer Experience
Level 3

Self-guided sales experience, self-admin capabilities, no barriers to sale via web, or phone. Easy signup and activation.

Online Customer Experience
Level 4

Integrated online knowledge-base and live-chat for both sales support and post-sales support. Pro-active email communication during first 30-60 days provides training, tips, tricks, etc.

Online Customer Experience
Level 5

Integrated up-sell and cross-sell activities into customer "control panel". Pro-active and ongoing customer feedback management (surveys of customer panels by segment to assess overall customer experience, satisfaction, and future needs).

Direct & Indirect Sales
Level 1

Direct sales only. No pro-active lead qualification. No customer segmentation by size or industry. Characterized by tendancy to focus too far up-market. Long sales cycles. Lack of "solution specialist" capability results in inability to overcome common objections.

Direct & Indirect Sales
Level 2

Direct Sales, indirect channels, telesales, but with ineffective processes for lead qualification and routing of leads to "best qualified" channel. Provider is actively working to train sales and revise processes to improve effectiveness.

Direct & Indirect Sales
Level 3

Pro-active management of direct sales, inside sales, and channel partners. Focus on customer segmentation and lead qualification. Pro-active training. Overlay sales team with deep solution expertise supports all channels.

Direct & Indirect Sales
Level 4

Integrated lead/opportunity flow for channel partners. Mature process for lead qualification and routing of leads. Customer segmentation and qualification "drives" the opportunity management. Willing to "walk away" from bad opportunities.

Direct & Indirect Sales
Level 5

Vertical or micro-market focused channel partners with lead flow integrated into micro-marketing campaigns. Channel partner branded sales sites. Integration of channel partner into knowledge base, live chat, etc.

Organizational Effectiveness
Level 1

Ad-hoc organizational and departmental behaviors with a lack of internal alignment towards achieving a common vision or business objectives.

Organizational Effectiveness
Level 2

Good executive leadership in place and committed to drive change and improve business performance by driving improvements in accordance with the "key success factors".

Organizational Effectiveness
Level 3

Organizational alignment around business objectives and customer needs. Organizational ability to repeatedly follow a relatively short and defined life-cycle for the successful introduction of new or revised product offerings.

Organizational Effectiveness
Level 4

Strong executive sponsorship for improving existing offerings and adding new value-added service offerings. Proven organizational agility and rapid time-to-market in response to competitive threats.

Organizational Effectiveness
Level 5

Organization is designed and internally aligned for change. Specific processes for continuous improvement. Healthy balance of management (stability) and leadership (fostering change).

Curious about how you can improve your Software+Services marketing?

Take a few moments to register your interest and we’ll get in touch with you directly.

See how you compare. Register Now


© 2009 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Contact Us |Terms of Use |Trademarks |Privacy Statement
Microsoft