June 17, 2003
The following is a summary of the allegations contained in the 15 antispam lawsuits filed by Microsoft Corp. on June 16 or 17, 2003, in the United States and the United Kingdom.
United States Case Summaries
Filed in Washington State, King County Superior Court:
Defendants: Email Gold Inc., Linda Jean Lightfoot, Eddie Davis and NetGold Inc., Dayton, Ohio. Case number: 03-2-27982-0 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Sent unsolicited e-mail advertising a CD with all the tools necessary to become a high-volume spammer
Continued to send unsolicited e-mail after receiving a "cease and desist" letter from Microsoft
Offered to sell 30 million e-mail addresses and software that enabled would-be spammers to disguise their identities and the origin of unsolicited e-mail
Offered would-be spammers advice on how to target their e-mail campaigns to countries around the world. For example, for Switzerland, they said "STAY AWAY FROM THIS ONE!" ; for Germany, they warned "[It] Has passed tough anti-UCE laws)" ; for New Zealand, "Good email market here--many leads" ; for Sweden, "AVOID***AVOID***AVOID!!!!" ; and for the U.K., "Excellent Market Here!"
Falsely identified msn.com and hotmail.com as the origin of their unsolicited e-mail; used those domains without permission; and used the domains aol.com, yahoo.com, as well as several domains from Switzerland and Brunei Darussalam, without permission
Misrepresented and obscured the point of origin of their unsolicited e-mail messages
Defendant: The E-Offer Store, Haddonfield, N.J. Case number: 03-2-27985-4 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Sent unsolicited e-mail with deceptive subject lines that make recipients believe they had a pre-existing business or personal relationship with the sender
Products and services advertised included dating services, debt counseling, prizes, home business products, mortgage refinancing, credit cards, car loans, class reunion sites and prepaid legal services.
Sent unsolicited e-mail from freebigdealzzz.com, freebigdealzzz.net, freetreasurezzz.co and freetreasurezzz.net
Defendants: Giantlinks Inc. and the PlanetClick Holding Co., New York. Case number: 03-2-27986-2 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Sent unsolicited e-mail with false and misleading subject lines to MSN Hotmail® account holders advertising various multilevel marketing schemes and a debt consolidation service
Sent unsolicited e-mail from the giantlinks.com domain
Defendant: Global Media Inc., Ft. Lauderdale, Fla. Case number: 03-2-27979-0 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Defendants: Interweb Hosting LLC, Philip Adelberg, Interweb Hosting Inc. and IWH, Pittsburgh. Case number: 03-2-27980-3 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Sent unsolicited e-mail from spoofed third-party domain names (hotmail.com, msn.com, aol.com, yahoo.com, ibm.com and juno.com)
Sent unsolicited e-mail with deceptive subject lines that make recipients believe they had a pre-existing business or personal relationship with the sender
Obscured the point of origin of the unsolicited e-mail
Sent unsolicited e-mail advertising "executive level" business opportunities, an online golf game that could be used to "have fun" and "make big money," Internet-based skill training, and corporate promotion services
Defendant: John Doe, United States. Case number: 03-2-27987-1 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Sent unsolicited commercial e-mail from spoofed third-party domain names to MSN Hotmail account holders, advertising nudeitv.com, an adult Web site
Sent unsolicited e-mail that did not include an "unsubscribe" link or any other means to allow the recipient to request that defendant stop sending him or her the unsolicited e-mail
Defendant: RHC Direct LLC, Murray, Utah. Case number: 03-2-27983-8 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Sent unsolicited commercial e-mail with false and misleading subject lines to MSN Hotmail account holders
Advertised products and services ranging from videotapes teaching interview and job-hunting skills to contests, sweepstakes and multilevel marketing schemes
Sent unsolicited e-mail from dailycomnet.com
Defendant: Rockin Time Holdings Inc., Miami. Case number: 03-2-27977-3 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Defendant: TranzAct Media Inc., New York (registered in Delaware). Case number: 03-2-27984-6 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Sent unsolicited e-mail with false and misleading subject lines to MSN Hotmail account holders advertising various products and services, including dating services, prizes and home loan refinancing
Sent messages from deal-seeker.com
Defendants: VMS Inc. and Proform4Life Inc., Port Richey, Fla. Case number: 03-2-27978-1 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Defendant: XPAYS Inc., San Francisco. Case number: 03-2-27988-9 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Sent unsolicited e-mail containing explicit images
Used misleading subject lines and spoofed third-party domains, including hotmail.com, msn.com and other domains as the originating e-mail address
Defendants: John Does 1--20, Chardon, Ohio. Case number: 03-2-27981-1 SEA
Alleged spam activity:
Filed in United States District Court, Central District of California:
Defendant: PointCom Inc. (a California corporation); Joshuathan Investments (a foreign entity using a Belize address); JOHN DOES 1-20, Canoga Park, Calif.; and Belize City, Belize. Case number: 03-4269 VBKx
Alleged spam activity:
Identified two distinct spam campaigns. The first campaign consisted of messages that contained the subject line "WINDOWS UPDATE NOTIFICATION" and were addressed to "registered member," with the actual recipient's name hidden. The body of the messages state that the e-mail is a "WINDOWS SECURITY WARNING!!" The messages state that "A VIRUS HAS BEEN DETECTED ON YOUR COMPUTER. IN ORDER FOR YOUR COMPUTER NOT TO CRASH YOU WILL NEED TO GO TO" defendants' Web site and download defendants' toolbar. The e-mail messages falsely informed the recipient that the toolbar "WILL AUTOMATICALLY UPDATE YOUR COMPUTER'S SECURITY PATCHES." The e-mail message also said that if the recipient did not download defendants' product, he or she would "KEEP RECEIVING THIS SECURITY ALERT EMAIL EVERY DAY."
The second spam campaign falsely implied that the originating message was from Microsoft. Its subject line was "Microsoft Ietoolbar update." The body of the message was an HTML image that makes extensive use of Microsoft's trademarks and service marks
Both campaigns and the toolbar violate trademark law.
United Kingdom Case Summaries
Filed in the High Court Justice; Royal Courts of Justice, London:
Defendant: John Doe, United Kingdom
Alleged spam-related activity:
Defendant: John Doe, United Kingdom
Alleged spam-related activity:
Used computer-generated addresses in an attempt to harvest/confirm the validity of MSN e-mail addresses for future spam distribution and/or resale
Defendant spoofed the sender of the unsolicited e-mail to ensure that reply messages would be rerouted to a London-based antispam organization.