Service Management Functions

Service Desk

On This Page
Document PurposeDocument Purpose
Executive SummaryExecutive Summary
Processes and ActivitiesProcesses and Activities
Roles and ResponsibilitiesRoles and Responsibilities
Relationship to Other ProcessesRelationship to Other Processes
ContributorsContributors

Document Purpose

This guide provides detailed information about the service desk service management function (SMF) for organizations that have deployed, or are considering deploying, Microsoft technologies in a data center or other type of enterprise computing environment. This is one of the more than 20 SMFs defined and described in Microsoft® Operations Framework (MOF). The guide assumes that the reader is familiar with the intent, background, and fundamental concepts of MOF as well as the Microsoft technologies discussed.

An overview of MOF and its companion, Microsoft Solutions Framework (MSF), is available in the Introduction to Service Management Functions guide. This overview guide also provides abstracts of each of the service management functions defined within MOF. Detailed information about the concepts and principles of each of the frameworks is also available in technical papers available at http://www.microsoft.com/solutions/msm/.

Executive Summary

Providing a high-level of service is expensive and time consuming. While business leaders are looking for economic ways to assist their customers, they are also looking for ways to realize their economic strategies. They want their support responses to be efficient and effective. When a customer has a problem, complaint, or question, the leaders want their customers to receive quick answers, straightforward resolutions, and accurate results.

The service desk is the first point of contact for the company; its efficient and effective response to customer's problems and concerns can do much to enhance the reputation of the company. The service desk also provides an organized and coordinated front line to its technical support staff members who are working independently in various geographical locations.

Processes and Activities

Service Desk Overview

A major advantage of a service desk is the fact that it is a single point of contact for customers and service technicians. It delivers quick and responsive resolutions to busy individuals located all over the world, and that small fact can be the difference between an organization's success and failure.

The service desk provides communication, information, and resolutions to customers who have issues with their IT infrastructure. Some of the company's problems might include:

No structured customer support mechanism is in place.

The customer has low confidence in the IT department.

The organization has outgrown its support system.

The support resources are under managed.

The support resources continually spend time resolving mini-crises or solving the same problems.

The support resources are interrupt-driven.

There is an over dependency on key staff.

The IT department lacks focus on the project at hand.

Uncoordinated and/or unrecorded changes take place.

The business leaders and/or workers are unable to cope with changes.

Staff resources and cost requirements are unclear.

The quality of call response and response times are inconsistent.

There is a lack of management information on which to base decisions.

Defining support processes (including definition of roles and responsibilities) and adopting a consolidated approach to customer and user support helps overcome and enhance the organization's success ration.

Goals and Objectives

It is extremely important to clearly define and document the purpose and goals of the service desk. Creating a mission statement or a broad definition of the goals that clearly define the organization's approach to providing support is one way to accomplish this purpose.

Defining objectives early in the planning stage of the project enables all team members to be in alignment with what the company hopes to accomplish. Depending on the type of service the company intends to provide through the service desk, these objectives will be based on a number of factors, such as the size of the organization and the defined scope of the service desk function. Sample objectives might include:

Providing a single and central point of contact between users and the IT department.

Providing an interface for users to other service management functions, such as change management, problem management, configuration management, release management, and so on.

Delivering the high-quality support required for achieving business goals.

Identifying and lowering the total cost of ownership (TCO) of IT services.

Supporting changes across business, technology, and process boundaries.

Improving customer satisfaction.

Retaining all customers.

Identifying additional business opportunities.

Key Definitions

The following are key terms within the service desk function.

Call. A call is any communication by a customer to the service desk, regardless of the method of communication (telephone, e-mail, voice-mail, and so on).

Incident. An incident is an event, which is not part of the standard operation of a service, and could cause an interruption to or a reduction in the quality of service.

Major incident. A major incident is an incident with a high or potentially high impact and requires a response that is above and beyond that given to normal incidents. Typically, major incidents require cross company coordination, management escalation, the mobilization of additional resources, and increased communications.

Service request. A service request is a request for new or altered service. The types of service requests vary between organizations, but common ones include requests for change (RFCs), requests for information (RFIs), and service extensions.

Problem. A problem is identified as the undiagnosed root cause of one or more incidents.

Known error. A known error is an incident or problem for which the root cause is known and for which a temporary workaround or a permanent alternative has been identified. If a business case exists, an RFC will be raised, but, in any event, it remains a known error unless it is permanently fixed by a change.

Workaround. The workaround is an identified means of resolving a particular incident by allowing normal service to be resumed; however, it does not actually resolve the issue that caused the incident in the first place.

Solution/ permanent fix. A solution/permanent fix is an identified means of resolving an incident or problem that provides a resolution for the underlying cause.

Initial support team. The initial support team is the team providing the very first line of support for processing incidents and service requests. The initial support team is responsible for trying to resolve incidents at first contact, either by identifying known workarounds, using diagnostic scripts, or their own knowledge. In many organizations the service desk acts as the initial support team.

Resolution group. Resolution groups are specialist teams that resolve incidents and service requests that initial support cannot resolve. Support team structures vary between organizations, with some using a tiered structure (second-tier, third-tier), while others use platform- or application-oriented teams (mainframe team, desktop team, network team, database team).

Service Desk Structure

There are a number of different ways to provide service desk facilities within an organization. Deciding which structure to use must be made during the planning phase. (Other documents describe how to structure a service desk; however, a brief explanation is included here as some of the process considerations described later may depend on the selected structure.)

Table 1 Service Desk Structures

Service Desk TypeRequirementsToolsAdvantages

Centralized

A centralized service desk supports all users within the organization, regardless of their geographical location.

Clear leadership and a coherent mission.

Note: Even centralized service desks might use resolution groups that may be decentralized and/or based where the users are based.

A telephone system that allows users to call a single number to access the service desk.

This tool might include: Interactive Voice Response (IVR), Automatic Call Distribution (ACD), and Computer-Telephony Integration (CTI) to receive incoming calls.

An e-mail account used by the service desk receives e-mailed calls from users and sends responses from the service desk.

Access to the tools that support the service desk processes—call logging, monitoring, reporting, and so on. This will probably involve network connections to a server running the tools.

Users know where to call for support.

Fewer staff may be required, which reduces training, equipment, and facility costs.

Consolidated management overview.

Decentralized

A decentralized service desk has a number of service desks located at various geographical locations.

When the business needs are common across multiple locations, it is efficient to create one service desk to service the common-need, multiple locations.

It is important that clear channels of communication exist among the sites. Localized skills should be known and made available to other service desk sites.

This approach makes it easier to cover users based in multiple time zones.

The hardware and software should be compatible.

Common management reporting metrics should be used.

Each service desk must have access to common documentation/

resource library.

The ability to pass or escalate requests between service desks should be available.

Common processes for logging calls, escalation, reporting, and so on.

A common tool for supporting the service desk (or at least a shared database).

Common values must be defined for impact, severity, priority, status codes, closure categories, and so on.

It is possible that different tools will be used at different locations; however, it is recommended that the same basic set of tools be used by all distributed service desks in order to facilitate contingency arrangements whereby one location can temporarily take on the work of another location in the event of a disaster.

Provide customized support for specific location-based groups or staff.

Staff can develop a deeper level of expertise specific to the location.

Providing support in multiple languages is easier if the service desk supporting each language group can be staffed from local native speakers of that language.

Each service desk provides backup to other service desks in the event that one should become unavailable (disaster, and so on).

Distributing the service desks creates a broader labor pool to draw from.

Virtual Service Desk

The virtual service desk is based upon advances in network performance and telecommunications— the physical or geographical location of the service desk is immaterial.

A virtual service desk combines elements of both the centralized and decentralized service desks in that users utilize a consistent route to access the service desk, but their call may be routed to any one of a number of locations, depending on a number of factors (time of day, local public holidays, call volumes, and so on).

A common call logging and tracking tool must be used, which is accessible from all service desks.

The same processes and procedures must be used across all service desks to ensure consistency of service.

These points are even more important in a virtual service desk environment than they are in a decentralized service desk structure since all service desks support the same user population, and calls are handed from one service desk to another. It is important to ensure that call ownership is maintained to consistent standards across all service desks.

If a virtual service desk covers multiple language areas, a common language should be agreed upon for the logging of calls.

A telephone system is required that allows all users, regardless of location, to access the virtual service desk by using a consistent telephone number.
Note: This does not necessarily mean that the same telephone number should be used from all user locations, since it is beneficial for each user to call a local number. It means that when one service desk takes over from another, users do not have to use a different telephone number to contact the service desk (each user has a single telephone number for the service desk), and they do not need to know the routing of the call.

The telephone system must be capable of routing all calls made to all local service desk numbers through to the currently active service desk location. It must be possible to switch the target location either manually or on the basis of such conditions as time of day.

If more than one service desk location is active at the same time, the telephone system must be able to route incoming calls to the most appropriate location, based on such factors as origin of call, call queue lengths, and so on.

All service desks must use the same centralized tools. Calls that are logged by one service desk must be available to all other service desks for reference and for updating. This will probably require each of the service desks to have adequate network connections to a central data center running the tools.

This structure allows a "follow the sun" approach, where 24-hour coverage can be provided, with each service desk working only during the normal workday for its location.

As each service desk finishes work for the day, the calls are then routed to another service desk in a different time zone where the staff is just starting their workday.

Service Desks in Smaller Support Units

Smaller organizations may not have a separate service desk; however, the service desk processes would be provided by the staff that provides second line support.

The central point of contact might be a single telephone number within the support unit and/or an e-mail address for e-mailed calls. Responsibility for picking up calls (phone or e-mail) should be allocated to a rotation of support staff. There is a likelihood that a high percentage of calls will be fixed at first contact, since the people taking the calls are usually the support specialists.

Scaling Service Desks to Larger Organizations

Large organizations usually require full-range service desks. Providing service desk support on a large scale presents some unique challenges, as well as some opportunities for efficiencies.

The large-scale service desk has the opportunity and the obligation to make its operations more efficient. The opportunity is there because economies of scale become more significant as the size of the service desk increases, diversifies, and fine-tunes its workload in ways not available to smaller operations. It is also an obligation because inefficiencies develop on a much more significant scale. Inefficiencies that were either unavoidable or insignificant in a small service desk can quickly become costly for the larger service desk.

Optimizing the efficiency of the service desk is discussed later in this document (see Optimize_Service_Desk).

The Service Desk Within the IT Organization

The service desk provides the focal point for customer access to the IT organization. It acts both as an interface between customers and IT functions and as a filter ensuring that IT staff members can complete their work in a structured way without interruption.

The service desk also provides a front-end focal point for other service management functions and processes.

Figure 1 illustrates how the service desk interacts with other entities.

Figure 1: Service desk interactions

Figure 1: Service desk interactions
See full-sized image.

Scope

As mentioned, one of the goals of the service desk is to provide a single point of contact for the IT organization. The question of scope addresses who receives access and the types of contacts.

Who Does the Service Desk Support?

Many organizations implement some form of central point of contact for customer or user issues. This function can be known by any of a number of titles, such as a help desk or call center. The following table is a list of the various titles and a description of each:

Table 2 Central Points of Contact

FunctionDescription

Call Center

A call center is usually the term used for a function that handles a large volume of telephone-based transactions for the external customers of an organization—for example, banks, utility companies, mail order companies. Typically, there are two types of call centers: inbound and outbound. Inbound call centers typically take calls from customers in response to print, radio, or television advertising.

Outbound call centers typically contact customers to make sales or telemarketing calls.

Some call centers actually combine the two types by having the representatives divide their time between inbound and outbound activities.

Customer Hot Line

A customer hot line normally deals with calls from external customers—possibly complaints, product queries, product orders, help, and advice.

Help Desk

A help desk provides support to users or customers internal to the organization. Personnel from the help desk manage, coordinate, and resolve issues as quickly as possible. They also record all issues.

Service Desk

A service desk is primarily aimed at users of an organization's IT infrastructure; however, it extends the range of services to offer a more business-focused approach. This allows business processes to be integrated into the service management framework.

The service desk not only handles incidents, problems, and requests for information, it also provides a route for customers to interact with all IT processes, including change requests, procurement, service level management, job scheduling, and so on. The customers supported by a service desk may be internal users of an organization's IT infrastructure, or they may be external customers who also have cause to access an organizations IT infrastructure.

What Does the Service Desk Do?

As to what types of contact are supported, there are two major categories: incidents and service requests. The following table describes each of these categories:

Table 3 Types of Contact

CategoryDescriptionFunction

Incident

An incident is a single occurrence of an event, which is not part of the standard operation of a service. An incident may cause an interruption to the normal operation of a service or a reduction in the quality of that service.

The function of the service desk in this case is to facilitate the restoration of the service to the affected users as quickly as possible.

Service Request

A service request could be any one of the following examples:

A request for change.

A request for information (that is, a query).

An as-needed job request.

A procurement request.

Any communication between a user and the IT department (for example, a complaint, compliment, comment, or suggestion).

The function of the service desk in the case of a service request is to ensure that the request is dealt with to the satisfaction of the user, either by satisfying the request directly or by allocating the request to an appropriate resolution group.

Benefits of a Service Desk

The service desk provides vital day-to-day contact points between customers, users, IT services, and third-party support organizations. For customers, the service desk is very important, because it is their only exposure to the organization's level of service and professionalism.

A service desk is the bridge between the users and the technical staff supporting the services. Its objectives are to provide the following:

Infrastructure management to ensure that changes are recorded and support is focused on problem areas.

Positive experience with and perception of the IT department's capabilities.

Proactive approach to provided service delivery.

Fewer interruptions to business functions.

Improved business productivity.

Implementing a service desk provides the following benefits to an organization:

Improved customer service that augments the customer's perception of the IT department service delivery capabilities and increases customer satisfaction.

Increased accessibility to the functions of the IT department through a single point of contact, providing a channel for communication and information.

Better quality of responses and speedier turnaround of customer requests.

Improved teamwork and communications both within the IT department and with customers of the IT function.

Enhanced focus on support requirements.

A proactive approach to service provisions.

A better understanding of the business processes supported by IT services, leading to a reduced negative business impact.

Better-managed IT infrastructure and better control of its development.

Improved use of support resources and increased productivity of business personnel.

A basis on which to charge for benefits provided by the support desk.

The service desk can provide meaningful management information to support the business decision-making process. Information that can be provided by the service desk includes:

Staff resource usage

Service deficiencies

Service performance and target achievement

Customer training needs

Associated costs

In addition to the tangible benefits listed above, a service desk provides value to an organization in that it:

Acts as a strategic function to identify and lower the cost of supporting the IT and support infrastructure.

Supports the integration and management of change across distributed business, technology, and process boundaries.

Reduces costs by enabling more efficient use of resources and technologies.

Supports the optimization of investments and management of the business support services.

Helps to ensure long-term retention and satisfaction of external customers.

Assists in the identification of business opportunities.

Major Processes

The major processes within the service desk service management function (SMF) are:

Operate service desk.

Optimize service desk.

Operate Service Desk

The operate service desk process addresses the tasks required to manage day-to-day service desk activities, including:

Table 4 Process Tasks

TaskDescription

Managing resources on a day-to-day basis.

Ensure that expected call volumes and profiles are monitored and tracked for numbers and skill levels of staff.

Communicating with customers.

Build customer relationships and is both proactive and reactive.

Performing service desk processes.

Provide the information and control required by other SMFs and manage the interfaces between the service desk and the other SMFs.

Promoting and marketing the service desk.

Encourage using the service desk facilities and advertise its capabilities.

Managing the costs

Record and track costs for having a service desk and recover the costs by charging customers and users.

Monitoring the performance of service desk staff.

Monitor resources, processes, tools, third parties, and customer satisfaction.

Preparing reports.

Prepare all reports required by management.

Figure 2 depicts the tasks that must be performed daily when managing a service desk.

Figure 2: Day-to-day service desk tasks

Figure 2: Day-to-day service desk tasks

Managing Staff and Resources

In order to deliver high-quality service through a service desk, it is necessary to provide properly trained staff to process the incoming calls. The service desk staff requires technical, communication, and even language skills, if the service desk provides an international service.

Scheduling Staff

Two of the various ways to schedule staff for the service desk are described in the following table:

Table 5 Scheduling Models

Scheduling TypesDescriptionBasis of Scheduling

Deadline-driven groups

Used to schedule computer support personnel who focus on software development or hardware maintenance. The group has a set of deliverables or tasks that must be completed by a specific date or time.

Project management systems are typically used to schedule these milestones.

Achieving milestones, not performing the work at any specific time or day.

Demand-driven model

Used to schedule service desk resources.

Requires accurate prediction of customer needs; this is typically based on historical data and known events/issues, such as new releases, implementing changes, or new business initiatives.

Being available to respond to users when issues occur, which reflect the hours the users are working with their equipment. The hours worked are often determined by the pattern of calls made by users.

While users may tolerate a certain amount of automated, front-end answering systems, it is important for them to be able to connect quickly to a live voice that can immediately respond to their problem. This live voice increases confidence in the service desk and usually decreases frustration. Both described methods require a live voice to receive a call. If most of the service desk personnel are away and user requests go unattended for long periods of time, service desk credibility and effectiveness are reduced.

A flexible, efficient, and user-friendly scheduling system is especially important for presenting a seamless infrastructure to customers. Service desks are typically established to reduce overall company costs by:

Minimizing system downtime.

Decreasing end-user learning curves.

Reducing the dependence and cost associated with requiring external support from vendors, such as hardware companies, software companies, and consultants.

Unless efficiency is built in to ensure service desk resources are available at crucial work times, other departments might incur additional costs, which would negate the savings realized by the presence of the service desk.

Creating a Schedule

The number of people required to staff a service desk is usually determined during a planning phase. When assigning personnel to specific work schedules, the two most important considerations are:

What hours will the service desk be open for business?

How many individuals must be available to staff the desk for those hours?

Establishing the service desk's open hours is very important. A service desk can be scheduled to span specific times during regular business hours, or the services might be required 24-hours-a-day, 7-days-a-week (often referred to as 24/7). This information should be determined during the planning phases of the service desk project.

Once the hours are established, it is possible to assign individuals to work specific shifts and provide adequate coverage throughout the appropriate time frames.

Another possibility to consider when determining schedules is the personal preferences of staff members. If requirements for the service desk span more than the typical 8 A.M. to 5 P.M. business hours, it might be possible to allow various unorthodox schedules, such as:

Individuals might work later or earlier shifts.

Individual might work four 10-hour days as opposed to five 8-hour days.

Other creative schedules that may benefit the individual and the organization.

Scheduling Models

A variety of theories and methodologies govern scheduling models. The following table describes five different approaches suitable for service desk organizations. There is no one best-suited scheduling method that is optimal for all organizations; therefore, an outline of each scheduling model is included in Figure 3. The outline is a guide and point of discussion to help plan the methodology that might be appropriate for an organization's service desk.

Table 6 Scheduling Approaches

TypeDescription

Key

Refers to the column headings in the Scheduling Methods outline, where each scheduling method shown in the table row headings is described in detail.

Staff

Split into three categories, according to the number of staff a service desk might require.

Experience

Divided into three categories: new or temporary service desk analysts, regular service desk analysts, and senior, or very experienced, service desk analysts.

Type

Indicates two types of support provided: the first tier provides general assistance and the second tier provides specialized support.

Manager

Shows how much management time a given scheduling method requires. Management time spent on schedule implementation is broken down into time spent at startup (during the initial stages of the change) and time spent after the change becomes standard operating procedure.

Note: This is not the time it takes to build the schedule, but is its actual implementation by staff day-by-day.

Figure 3: Scheduling model outline

Figure 3: Scheduling model outline
See full-sized image.

The following sections contain broader descriptions for each of the scheduling models:

Half-Hour Schedules

Service desk managers may want to schedule staff members in half-hour increments for their entire phone day. This is possible if one has a known and forecasted phone call arrival rate based on half-hour increments. One can schedule the appropriate number of employees to staff the telephones in half-hour increments, which will meet the demand. The forecasted arrival rate is based on historical patterns and forecasts to determine the staff needed during any given 30-minute interval. In theory, this approach can deliver the correct number of personnel at the right time.

Table 7 Half-Hour Schedules

AdvantagesRisksDependencies

Staff members know exactly when they are taking calls.

This system is time-intensive to implement.

A responsible person must create advanced schedules for each service desk group.

Managers know exactly who should be on the phones.

It is dependent on 100-percent schedule adherence, or service levels may suffer.

This model only applies to phone-based or immediate support.

A good forecast, coupled with knowledge of daily call patterns, can make the half-hour model extremely efficient for high volume queues.

Changes to the established schedule need to be adjusted with a new schedule or other compensating factor. These changes can significantly add to the effort expended in scheduling.

Where applicable, cross-site communication, cooperation, and policy agreement are needed for smooth execution.

The shorter the scheduling increment, the more effective the service desk is in meeting service level requirements.

This approach does not allow staff to take time off the phone without making additional arrangements. This level of availability can only be maintained if all related policies and procedures support the model.

The schedule must account for required work breaks as dictated by local employment laws.

Recommendations

This system is most effective in fluctuating, high-volume, and demand-driven environments, where adherence to service delivery levels is the highest priority. It is labor intensive and rigid, which can be both advantageous and detrimental. It is best in queues where arrival and staffing are relatively predictable and not subject to large shifts in pattern. It is not the best solution for small groups with small service demands, as these are more likely to exhibit the largest demand variances (by percentage)—a phenomenon sometimes referred to as small queue syndrome. It is also not recommended for responsive delivery models such as callback or e-mail support.

 

 

Self-Managed Teams (Pods)

While the self-managed team is the most ambitious strategy presented in this guide, it also has the potential for the largest return.

Each team (sometimes referred to as a pod) normally undertakes tier 1 calls and tier 2 (and possibly tier 3) support responsibilities, with members of the team moving between the roles as demand dictates.

A self-managed team is either unscheduled—the team has a shift time (for example, 8 A.M. to 5 P.M.) and a scheduled lunch break, but otherwise team members are responsible for taking calls when the calls need taking—or they develop their own schedule as required by the demand model and service levels. Service desk personnel in this model may or may not have specific phone hour goals. This is a departure from most models, and the scope of the philosophical change must not be underestimated. It has been proven to work in some organizations, but it takes a mature group of people to accomplish this successfully.

Table 8 Self-Managed Teams

AdvantagesRisksDependencies

The effort required to schedule service desk resources may be reduced. With only shift and lunch breaks scheduled (although lunch breaks can be self-managed), service desk management focuses less on scheduling, more on productivity analysis.

Without commitment and occasional monitoring, the system might be subject to abuse.

This system is dependent on having a service culture within the staff and people who feel compelled to do the right thing. There may be service delivery and other goals, but how these goals are met is up to the team and each individual member.

Training employees to think about what's best for the business in addition to what's best for meeting my metric-based goals requires time and effort and might involve rethinking the companys reward or review system.

Service desk resources would take the same number of calls spread out over a longer period of time (if staffed correctly). The number of staff taking calls can be adjusted so that all calls are answered within the agreed responsiveness targets without having analysts sitting around waiting for calls to arrive. This should be particularly apparent in morning and evening times when all staff members are available but call volume is below daily peak.

service desk's with large queues may find this system more challenging to implement because there is less control if service levels become a problem.

While there may no longer be a schedule, there most definitely needs to be accountability as well as strong guidelines to help people make the right phone decisions. Labor on and off the designated queue can be tracked and can serve as one possible method to ensure accountability.

Managers need to coach service desk personnel on handling phone calls and on how to make decisions. Guidelines, such as how staff should manage themselves, what the goals of the group are, and so on, are critical to early success or failure.

Service desk personnel, who have first-hand knowledge of incoming call conditions, make their own decisions regarding other tasks they must do, such as scheduling meetings, callbacks, research, and so on.

Managers overseeing queues with large numbers of temporary, new, or inexperienced staff may find self-management difficult.

Management policies must be consistent, clearly communicated, and supportive at all levels. If management support is not strong and visible, self-management strategies will fail.

Call spikes can be handled much more consistently because all available staff can cover the phones as needed, resulting in higher service levels and less time waiting for calls.

 

The schedule must account for legal issues pertaining to breaks for temporary personnel.

Recommendations

The potential gains for self-managed teams are fewer resources required for scheduling tasks and a more flexible work schedule for the staff, as well as more ownership in the business, while maintaining high levels of customer satisfaction. Self-managed teams are probably best suited to service desk's with experienced staff and small queues, or in specialized groups with small teams, whose members are excellent communicators and more experienced.

 

 

Triads (or Triad-like Models)

Triad models are similar to self-managed teams; however, they usually operate on a smaller scale and with increased accountability. Typically, three people, all on the same shift, form a triad that functions with at least two of the three people on the phones at any given time. They rotate throughout the day so that each spends a specific period of time on his or her respective activities (such as six hours on delivery and two hours on non-delivery activities), depending on the goal.

While triad methodology usually requires more staff scheduling than self-managed teams, utilizing triad models at multiple sites in multiple time zones can greatly help meet service demand. Triads give flat per-half-hour delivery and may not meet the service demand without some adjustments. Also, triads require several people to act as floaters to fill holes when a triad member is not available.

Table 9 Triads

AdvantagesRisksDependencies

The service desk manager can significantly reduce the scheduling burden, both in making the actual schedules and in changing them once they are made.

Some scheduling and control are needed to ensure that the arrival pattern, or the rate at which phone calls are coming in, is met with the essentially flat distribution of triads. Maintaining shifts can improve control.

As with all plans, goals and guidelines need to be laid out and supported consistently by all concerned.

Service desk personnel have greater flexibility without necessarily sacrificing service delivery levels, and they can make changes in shift staffing at any time.

Managers need to be aware of anyone in the triad who needs to be monitored. Goals need to be established to ensure that members of a triad, at least over time, are pulling equal weight.

Triad members need to work well together as a team.

 

For small queues, triads may not be an effective strategy in response to high service demand.

 

Recommendations

Triads are appropriate in a medium-sized queue, but a large group with an inexperienced staff may limit a purely self-directed team approach. Triads are effective for demand requirements that are somewhat flat and consistent throughout the day.

 

 

Hybrid Peak-Scheduled/Off-Peak Self-Managed or Triads

Many service desks find a purely self-managed scheduling arrangement unsuitable for all staff or all demand scenarios. An alternative that helps guarantee coverage during critical times is to use formal schedules during peak hours only. For the remainder of the day, service desk managers can use self-managed scheduling or triads. This ensures control during the critical times and may be a good intermediate step toward full self-management.

Table 10 Hybrid-Peak Scheduled/Off-Peak Self-Managed or Triads

AdvantagesRisksDependencies

Peak hours are covered.

This model still requires some scheduling effort and the scheduling interval is probably smaller than with fully self-managed teams.

The dependencies are the same as for self-managed and triad models.

Some of the advantages of self-managed teams may be realized in this system as well, such as improved call spike handling and reduced scheduling.

The risks are the same as for the self-managed model.

 

Recommendations

The Hybrid Peak-Scheduled/Off-Peak Self-Managed or Triad model is a good stepping-stone method for groups working towards self-managed models or for managers who are concerned about sufficient coverage during critical periods.

 

 

Hybrid Scheduled/Self-Managed

Another alternative that provides some of the benefits of a self-managed schedule team is to use the half-hour schedule model for some employees, while allowing others to follow a shift-based, self-managed schedule. High volume business that uses only callbacks for second-tier support might find this model useful. However, for real-time second-tier support, managing this model is difficult because the first-tier staff needs a reliable, available second tier.

Table 11 Hybrid Scheduled/Self-Managed

AdvantagesRisksDependencies

Again, some of the advantages of self-managed teams are present in this model as well.

If part of the organization is self-managed, they must self-schedule to meet the support requirements of the part that is not self-managed. Accountability for meeting service delivery levels must be owned by the team.

Dependencies for this model are the same as for self-managed.

Control and flexibility can be increased or decreased according to the service delivery requirements.

The hybrid scheduled/self-managed model still requires some close attention to scheduling.

 

 

Managers must remember who is following which type of schedule.

 

Recommendations

This model may be effective for larger queues where both control and flexibility are needed to meet the customers needs. First-tier support may require the half-hour schedule, whereas second-tier support may require more flexibility in enabling second-tier engineers to help with first-tier calls during high volume times, but continue to concentrate on non-delivery, research, or callback issues at other times. In this case, self-managed does not mean unscheduled. The self-managed team must develop a schedule that ensures support is available to the first tier when it is needed for live mentoring or escalation. It may also be effective when applied to a mixed demand model where both immediate and responsive delivery types are required.

The choice of scheduling model depends on many factors, including size of the group, personal and collective preferences, developmental levels of service desk personnel, and so on. There is no best-fit model for any group, and some groups need to revisit these decisions frequently in order to maximize their efficiency.

 

 

Staff Absence

Scheduling must make allowances for absentee employees (both planned and unplanned). It must also make allowance for unexpected peaks or valleys in service desk activities. Unexpected periods of low activity will result in temporary over-staffing, so arrangements should be considered for surplus staff to perform other duties.

Technology note The scheduling of the service desk staff activities may be done manually if the service desk is relatively small. For larger service desks, it is appropriate to use a tool for scheduling. Resource-scheduling tools for the service desk range from Microsoft Excel spreadsheets through planning tools such as Microsoft Project to applications designed specifically for resource scheduling and allocation. A good call logging-and-tracking system may also include a resource-scheduling system as part of the resolution management portion of the application.

Staff Satisfaction and Retention

It is important for organizations to maintain staff satisfaction as well as customer satisfaction. Answering customer calls for long periods of time can be tedious and psychologically draining, as most people call the service desk to register a problem or complaint. Rotating the staff so they perform other duties as well as answering calls is one way to avoid staff frustration.

It is beneficial to retain employees who are technically adept and have the required amount of skill, training, and experience to work the service desk. This benefits the organization, the service desk manager, and the customers.

Note: Committed and motivated employees are less likely to pursue opportunities elsewhere; this retains experience and expertise for the service desk, reduces training costs, and provides solid continuity for the customers.

Individuals thrive in an environment that provides challenge, promotes open communication and teamwork, and facilitates success. Employee satisfaction influences customer satisfaction. Encourage employees to excel and provide the best possible product. It is important to monitor employee satisfaction regularly and address dissatisfaction issues as quickly as possible.

It is suggested that an organization focuses on three components that delineate the employee's relationship with the organization:

Employee-to-job. Employee satisfaction with his or her job, environment, and processes is measured by getting answers to such questions as:

Do you feel challenged by this job?

Do you know the mission of your group?

Do you like what you are doing?

Focus on determining how well the job matches the employee's needs. It is as important to identify what aspects of the job are rewarding as it is to identify the problem areas. Determine whether the job is meeting the employees current expectations and how it fits into the employees goals, which may include growing in the current position or moving up to the next level or on to new challenges.

Employee-to-manager. These questions relate to the supervisor's or manager's leadership style. They include such questions such as:

Have you and your manager established goals for your performance?

Do you feel comfortable talking with your manager about problems you are having?

When your manager gives you an assignment, is it clear?

This is also a good place to gather feedback on how the manager empowers the employee and how well the manager gives feedback, carries out daily tasks, and performs under deadlines.

Employee-to-coworker. Employee satisfaction levels with other members of the team are measured by getting answers to questions, such as:

How is the communication within the team?

Do things get done faster and better when addressed by the team?

Are there things that can and should be improved?

Is it easy for team members to do their jobs?

Do other members of the team help you succeed in your current position?

Organizations that effectively evaluate employee satisfaction are in a much better position to make improvements. The type of improvements necessary may vary; however, collecting information is a good place to start. Once the problem relationships are identified, it is easier to resolve the issue.

Involving Second-Line Support

In many organizations, there are dedicated staff who perform the service desk activities all of the time. In smaller organizations, it is possible that some functions might be completed by the same staff members who provide second-line support. Even in organizations where this is not the case, it is beneficial for second-line support staff to spend time on the service desk—this can have a number of benefits, such as:

The support staff gains the experience of customer contact, allowing them to appreciate the customers business needs and demands.

The support staff sees what processes are followed in receiving and logging incidents that are subsequently passed to resolution groups, thereby encouraging empathy between initial support and second-line staff.

The technical knowledge required to resolve incidents can be spread around the service desk staff, enabling a higher rate of incidents to be fixed by first-line support.

Support staff can identify technical or procedural issues related to their specialty that might affect the efficiency or effectiveness of contact and communication between the service desk and the resolution groups.

Communicating with Customers

The service desk provides a channel of communications wherein users and the IT department can interact. Remember that it is a two-way channel, which provides a mechanism for the IT department to supply information to its customers as well as obtaining information from them.

Single Point of Contact

One of the main advantages of a service desk is that it provides a single point of contact to the customer for all interactions they have with the support unit and the entire IT department. The single point of contact gives the customer a sense of assurance that their problem is being handled. It also enables the service desk to build a relationship with the customer that would not be possible if the customer had to deal with a variety of departments. The single point of contact is also significant in outward communication between the IT department and users.

Communication Methods

A service desk provides a number of ways to communicate. Traditionally, contact is through the telephone, with a direct link to a support technician. However, alternatives include the facsimile machine (fax) and e-mail. These three ways to communicate allow a customer to register a call without direct contact with a technician. The use of Automatic Call Distribution (ACD) systems directing a customer to the most appropriate service desk is cost-efficient and saves time.

Depending on the physical location of the service desk, it is possible for users to visit the service desk in person. This is sometimes called a walk-up contact. However, it is possible that this type of distraction will prevent the service desk staff from providing services to others. It should be clarified that the walk-up contacts are not to receive preferential treatment just because they are physically there.

It is also important to consider providing services for the hearing impaired, visually impaired, or individuals with other types of physical disabilities. Many users with disabilities use specialized software and hardware. Service desk staff must be aware of these components and be trained in their use.

Communications Tools and Technologies

There are a number of tools and technologies available to enhance communication between the user and the service desk, including the following:

Table 12 Tools

ToolsDescriptionExamples

Telephone

The most common, and often the easiest and most familiar, method of communicating with the service desk remains the telephone. Opportunities for clearer definition and explanation of an issue exist when the customer reporting the issue is interacting directly with the service desk analyst.

Tools available for use with telephone systems include:

Automatic call answering. The customers call is answered and a pre-recorded message and/or music play while the call is placed in a queue waiting for an available service desk staff member. An advantage is that the user is not left with a ringing tone, which should reduce the number of abandoned calls.

Disadvantages include:

A prerecorded message might sound insincere, especially if the user has to hold the line for a long time and hears the message several times.

If the user is not calling internally or by a toll-free number, the user will be charged for the call from when it is answered.

Interactive Voice Response (IVR) is an extension of the concept of automatic call answering. It enables pre-recorded menus of options to be read to the caller and allows the caller to select options from the menu by using the telephone keypad or, in some systems, by speaking when the required menu option is spoken by the system. By following the menu options, the caller can be directed to an appropriate pre-recorded message, can be invited to leave a message, or can be directed to the most appropriate group of service desk analysts.

Automated Call Distribution (ACD). When a call is received or when a call has been routed by an IVR system, ACD can be used to put the call through to the most appropriate service desk staff member. The choice could be based on a number of factors—appropriate skills, language, comparing the times since each analyst took a call, analysts dedicated to a particular customer or group of customers, and so on.

Caller Line Identification (CLI). This is a facility provided by telephone companies (or by private exchanges for internal calls) that informs the recipient of a call of the telephone number of the caller. Usually the telephone number of the caller is displayed on the telephone receiving the call. Internal telephone systems may also display the name of the person calling (assuming the caller is calling from his or her own desk). This facility enables a service desk staff member to know who is calling.

Computer-Telephony Integration (CTI). This allows the telephone system to be used as an interface into computer systems. This could be used to integrate the CLI facility with a service desk tool so that when a users call is answered, the user can be identified from the telephone he or she is calling from and information associated with that user, which is held on the tool, can be presented to the service desk staff member who handles the call. This mechanism is only useful for users who are based in a fixed location and does not work effectively for users who may call from a number of different locations. A more advanced use of CTI is to provide automated transactions so that a customers call can be handled without reference to a service desk analyst, or it may be used to capture information from the customer prior to the call being passed to a service desk analyst. An example of an automatic transaction might be obtaining an account balance from a bank. The customer selects the required transaction from a menu by using the telephone keypad and then is prompted to enter authentication details such as an account number and a personal identification number (PIN). The account balance is then "read" to the customer. An example of capturing data prior to the call being passed to a service desk analyst might be to ask the customer to enter his or her identification or payroll number or the asset code of a faulty component.

Voice mail can be used as an alternative to queuing users if there are no available service desk staff members to take the call. If voice mail is used, someone on the service desk must be made responsible for picking up the voice mails and responding to them within a reasonable time. The danger is that if the service desk is constantly busy with incoming calls, these will take priority over voice mail messages.

Online submittal mechanisms

There are a number of alternate ways to submit requests to the service desk, such as: e-mail, electronic forms, Web-based HTML forms, and newsgroups.

E-mail is an increasingly common method of communicating with a service desk. The ubiquity of e-mail makes it easy for customers to submit calls to the service desk. This method can probably be used instead of the telephone for less urgent calls.

The biggest drawback to e-mail is that it is essentially free-format; therefore, an e-mailed call may not provide a structured report of all the symptoms of an issue or the details of a request. However, e-mail forms can be developed for users to use to document all the relevant information.

E-mail systems can be configured to automatically respond to incoming e-mails so that a user can be informed that his or her e-mail has at least been successfully received.

Web-based HTML and electronic forms (e-forms) encourage customers to record the symptoms of problems and details of service requests in a detailed, structured way by providing a template that the customer can complete when submitting a call. Structured forms require the customer to provide the kind of information that would be requested in a typical telephone conversation. Using structured forms also eliminates much of the need for repeated requests for more information from the customer, thereby reducing the overall time required to resolve the incident or fulfill the request. A structured form also makes it easier for the service desk to analyze calls for support trends.

Ideally, an organization has an online submittal system integrated with its call-tracking software. Such systems tie directly into the incident-tracking system, automatically creating a formal record of the transaction. Submitting an incident on an electronic form generates an incident report within the tracking system. Information taken from the electronic submittal form can be used to automatically assign and route the incident to the appropriate support group.

However, as with voice mail, someone on the service desk must be given responsibility for monitoring incoming e-mails or forms input and responding to them.

Newsgroups, bulletin board system (BBS) forums, and public e-mail folders provide a way for customers to resolve queries without calling the service desk and opening a service call. Like the HTML and electronic forms, submittal by news forums and public folders creates an immediate electronic record of the transaction. When an article is posted to the forum, other users with the same query can read it and see for themselves how to resolve it.

Web-based HTML submittal is easily linked to online self-help resources, alerts about system status, and notifications to apply patches or upgrades. Such resources help the user answer queries without the assistance of the service desk.

Facsimile

(FAX)

The use of fax to communicate with a service desk is less prevalent since the increase in the use of e-mail, but it is still a mechanism that should be considered. Its one advantage is an extremely rapid transfer of documents and written communication from any point on the globe to another.

As with e-mails, the service desk can define standard forms to be used when raising a call by fax. If a standard form is provided in advance and submitted with appropriate information, faxes can be an acceptable choice for reporting issues or submitting requests. However, faxes have limited value because they usually require manual copying of the information into the call-logging system.

Faxes are useful for acquiring written approval for certain diagnostic processes. Unfortunately, the quality of transmission often makes the content difficult to read and possibly less accurate than other online submittal mechanisms. Document scanning and imaging systems may also be used for submitting incidents.

As with voice mail and e-mail, someone on the service desk should be made responsible for monitoring incoming faxes and responding to them.

Warning: The use of intelligent telephone systems, voice mail, e-mail, forms, and so on greatly benefit the service desk. They should not, however, be used as an electronic barrier. The careful set-up of automatic interactive systems is required to prevent the customer being passed around. If voice mail and e-mail are used, it is imperative that they be monitored regularly and responses sent promptly to the customer. Put service level agreements in place to maximize these technologies and ensure a consistent and high-quality service is maintained.

The acceptability of the use of such telephone system functions as automatic call answering, interactive voice response, and automatic call distribution can also be influenced by cultural considerations of the particular region or country.

Technology note:

Many system management tools provide the ability to detect problems or potential problems with the systems they monitor. They also enable the notification of these events to event management systems by Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMP) or other protocols.

These event management systems can be monitored by service desk staff who can resolve any relevant issues; however, in many cases service desk products have interfaces that allow other systems, such as event management systems, to automatically create (and in some cases to update) incidents. This allows for automatically detected issues to be raised as incidents, although it may still be necessary for the service desk to allocate them to the relevant support group. It is still the responsibility of the service desk to monitor and track these incidents.

Proactive Communications

The service desk should provide a channel for proactively providing information to customers. This information might include known issues that are likely to cause future problems or service interruptions, forthcoming changes (by means of the Forward Schedule of Changes), forthcoming releases of software (by means of the Release Schedule), maintenance activities, and so on.

If suitable tools are used to support the service desk function, the customers affected by specific infrastructure issues can be identified and advised of the situation. Advance warning of any potential problems minimizes the business impact of these issues and enhances the relationship between customers and the IT department.

Self-Tracking

Self-tracking is a mechanism that allows users to see the status of calls they have registered with the service desk. Users may want to see what progress has been made in resolving an incident or the progress of a change request through the change management process.

In some circumstances, it might be appropriate to allow users to record new incidents or service requests on the service desk system.

Many service desk tools have the ability to be accessed by means of a Web interface, allowing customers to view details held on the system without having to have proprietary client software installed on their computer. These tools may require users to log on, so that only those records associated with the specific user are displayed.

Role of the Service Desk in Major Incidents

In the event of a major incident occurring (a major incident is an incident that creates a major impact because it affects critical services and/or affects a large number of users), the role of the service desk as a channel of communications is extremely important.

The service desk staff is responsible for the following tasks:

Defining the impact of the incident.

Defining the effects of the incident.

Describing what users are affected.

Tracking all progress towards incident resolution.

Providing estimated timescales for final resolution.

Describing recovery actions that will be necessary after the incident is resolved.

This information should be provided to users as efficiently and effectively as possible. It should be supplied when users call the service desk and also provided through the proactive mechanisms described above.

When a major incident occurs, managers and technical staff must focus on incident resolution. This means that resources may not be available to conduct other issues that might occur, which in turn could result in service level agreements being breached. The service desk must take these issues into account when dealing with users of other services.

Performing Processes

The primary objective of the service desk is to act as a consistent interface between the users and the IT department. This section describes ways in which the service desk should interact and communicate with the IT functions of an organization.

Many of the functions performed by the service desk are performed on behalf of other service management functions (SMFs), most notably incident management and change management. However, several other SMFs are also affected. See Relationship_to_Other_Processes for additional information.

Technology note The interfaces between service management functions (SMFs) can be made more efficient and effective if the tools used to support these functions can be integrated.

Tools are available that can support a number of service management functions, including the service desk. In this case, where the same tool is used, integration of the service management functions is straightforward.

Where different tools are used, some effort may be required to achieve the desired level of integration. Most tools have some sort of external interface—often in the form of an Application Programming Interface (API) or support for industry-standard interfacing mechanisms, such as XML.

Receiving and Recording Calls

The service desk receives calls from users, gathers the relevant information, and then logs the calls. This correlates to the detection and recording elements of the detection, self service, and recording processes within the incident management SMF.

There are a number of things to consider when completing this function:

Telephone protocol. Service desk personnel should be given guidance on how to deal with customers when using a telephone. Standard greetings may be defined, such as "Good morning, IT service desk. Brian speaking. How may I help you?"

When a service desk receives calls for a number of different clients, the greeting may vary customer is calling.

It is important to note that telephone manners are very important. Service desk personnel must always be polite to callers, even when the caller is angry, upset, or abusive. Personnel should be trained to handle all types of caller—including extreme cases, such as excessively abusive callers—wherein the staff member must calmly terminate the call and report the issue to the service desk manager.

Standard scripts may be defined for personnel to follow. This ensures that relevant information is obtained from the caller and reduces the chance that the subsequent investigation and diagnosis will require the service desk to contact the customer a second time.

Managing call queues. Modern intelligent telephone systems allow calls to be directed to the appropriate individual who is available. These systems also enable personnel to indicate their availability for taking calls throughout the day. The staff member logs on to the telephone system at the start of his or her working day and logs off at the end of the day. However, during the day, the staff member can indicate when he or she is away from the telephone—for example, going to lunch, on a break, or performing an administrative function, such as completing the documentation from a previous call. This means that at any given time, several individuals who are nominally available to take calls have indicated that they are not available. This could lead to a situation where the number of incoming calls is greater than the number of personnel available to take the calls and the customer is queued to wait for the next free support representative. When this happens, immediately alert the supervisor of the situation, as the queued customer may decide to abandon the call, which could lead to an unsatisfied customer.

Maintaining accurate customer information. When a customer calls, confirm that the customers information is up-to-date and correct.

Data protection. Understand that some information provided by a customer may be either personal or confidential information. There are legal requirements regarding personal information that varies from one country to another. Be cautious and seek legal advice on the information that is retained, the length of time it is retained, and the purposes for which the information is being used.

Call monitoring. Many organizations record some or all of the calls they take. These are sometimes used for training purposes so that new staff can hear the types of calls that are received, the types of users making the calls, and how each type of call is handled by an experienced technician. Sometimes calls are recorded for the purposes of protecting the service desk from possible claims by customers concerning the information they were given or the way the calls were handled. Again, the legal requirements regarding the recording of calls vary from one country to another. Seek legal advice when planning this process.

Supervisory monitoring. There are telephone systems that allow a supervisor or the service desk manager to listen in on calls being handled by a service desk staff member. This can be used as part of the monitoring or appraisal of the technician's performance.

Recording information. The information recorded in the call logging system should be appropriate and sufficient to process the call. This can be accomplished by following pre-defined scripts or by using an expert system that leads the staff member through a structured set of questions.

The service desk should acknowledge receipt of each call by giving the user a unique reference that can be used to identify the call if the user calls to check progress or if a support engineer needs to contact the user for further information. For calls received by telephone, the call reference should be given to the user during the telephone conversation. For calls received by other methods, the call reference should be transmitted to the user by the most appropriate method—for example, for calls that originate by means of e-mail or a Web page, the call reference can be transmitted to the user by e-mail.

When a call is received at the service desk, the staff member must determine the type of call:

Incident

Service request

If it is a service request, the staff member must determine the type of request.

Incidents

An incident is any event that is not part of the standard operation of a service and might cause an interruption to that service or a reduction in the quality of the service.

If a call is determined to be an incident, the service desk personnel must secure and record information that is used within the incident management processes.

The incident category identifies the type of issue the user is experiencing; samples of incident categories might be:

Application problems, such as:

The service is not available.

There is a flaw with the application that prevents the use of a transaction type.

The database is full.

Hardware problems, such as:

The user is unable to connect to network.

The printer is not printing.

The file server is inaccessible.

For additional information on incident categories, see the incident management SMF guide.

Categories are used in:

The generation of reports.

When highlighting areas of the IT infrastructure that are causing incidents.

Deciding which categories to use depends on the requirements of the organization.

At this stage in the processing of an incident, the service desk should determine:

What services and users are affected?

What SLAs are or could be breached?

What initial priority should be assigned to the incident?

The priority is calculated from:

The impact of the incident on the business.

The urgency that a resolution or workaround is required.

Note: The definitions of priority levels are usually linked to target resolution times recorded in the service level agreements (SLAs).

Initial Support

This section of the incident management process describes how to check for known fixes or workarounds already created for the reported incident.

Each incident should be checked against all known errors. If the service desk tool is integrated with the problem management tool, this can be done automatically. If a match is found, the resolution can be implemented.

Service desk personnel might use the following suggestions when implementing a resolution:

Give the resolution details to the user to implement.

Schedule a meeting between the user and an engineer.

Apply a fix to the user's desktop. Service desk personnel can do this by using remote support tools, if they are in place.

Initiate a change request if other resolution personnel need to be involved—for example, if a server needs to be rebooted.

Note: Pass the incident to the relevant resolution group as soon as possible, since the activity may need to be carefully planned prior to initiating the change request.

Confirm with the user who made the call that the resolution was successful. If it was, close the incident; however, if it was not resolved, restart the process.

Link new incidents that match known errors to the known error record.

Note: Incidents that do not match known errors should be checked against existing problems currently being processed by problem management.

A problem is a condition that creates a significant impact; however, the cause is not known. A problem may be created as a result of a single significant incident or a number of separate incidents that exhibit common symptoms. If an incident is found to match a current problem, that incident should be linked to the problem record. This indicates the severity of the problem and enables all related incidents to be addressed when a solution or workaround is found.

If an incident does not match a known error or a current problem, service desk personnel should review former incidents to see if the issue occurred previously. If a match is found, and the previous incident was resolved, use the same resolution. If the previous incident is unresolved, link the incidents and inform problem management.

If no matches are found, service desk personnel should attempt to resolve the issue. If the service desk staff have an appropriate level of technical expertise, it may be possible to identify the cause of the incident and resolve the issue. If a resolution is not readily available, but there are available remote support tools, it may be possible to diagnose the cause of the incident and recreate it in order to obtain additional information.

If the service desk personnel are not able to offer a resolution to the user, the incident should be escalated to the appropriate resolution group. That group will further investigate the incident and diagnose a resolution.

Service Requests

If a call received by the service desk is not an incident, it is treated as a service request. There are several types of service requests; some of the common types are:

Request for change

Request for information

Request for an as-needed job to be run

Complaint/compliment/suggestion

The types of service requests handled by a particular service desk depend on the type and size of the organization and the service desk's defined scope.

In some cases, the service desk may be able to fulfill the service request. If this is not possible, service desk personnel should secure as much relevant information as possible and then initiate the appropriate interface for the service request type. It is recommended that scripts or templates be provided for personnel to follow for each type of service request.

See the incident management SMF guide for additional information on handling service requests.

Ownership, Monitoring, and Tracking

The service desk retains ownership of all received calls from inception to closure, regardless of whether they are closed at the first call or are passed to another resolution group.

The service desk must ensure that the record of each call is updated appropriately at each stage of its progress, indicating to whom the call has been passed and when, any contacts with the originating user, diagnostic exercises, actions taken by the resolution groups, and any proposed resolution.

It is the service desk's responsibility to ensure that incidents and service requests are dealt with in a timely manner by each resolution group, especially if a service level agreement might be breached. The service desk should track and monitor the status of all open calls. Furthermore, the service desk should keep users informed of progress with their calls.

Delegation Procedures

It is important to define procedures on how calls will be delegated from the service desk to other resolution teams. Ideally, it should be possible to electronically transfer the information from the calls, and the other team should be able to acknowledge receipt of the transfer. The resolution team should also indicate that it will accept responsibility for the call. If a call is incorrectly assigned, the receiving team may reject the call and pass it back to the service desk for further research on who might resolve the issue.

Note: If there is a dispute over the call's assignment, a senior service desk staff member with the appropriate authority and responsibility should resolve the dispute. Typically, this role can be assigned to the incident manager.

When an incident is transferred to a resolution group, depending on the priority of the incident, it may be acceptable for the group to receive the incident when monitoring its incident queues. However, depending on the priority of the incident, it may be appropriate to telephone them and inform them of the incident, its priority, and the fact that it has been sent to them.

Interface to Service Level Management

Service desk personnel should refer to the service level agreements if the incident requires information from the agreement. If the service level agreement is being affected in any way by an unresolved incident, inform the appropriate service desk manager. Service desk personnel and their manager should continue to track and monitor the incident until it is resolved.

Closing Incidents

Service calls or incidents should always be closed by the service desk, even if other groups resolved the issue. The service desk closes the issue as part of its tasks in the incident management process. In many cases, the service desk is responsible for communicating the resolution details to the user who initiated the call.

It is important for the service desk to confirm that the resolution was satisfactory by checking with the initiating user. The incident should be closed only after the user has accepted the resolution.

Promoting and Marketing the Service Desk

Improving the overall reputation of the service desk is critical to the success of the IT support organization. Develop a strategy for promoting and marketing the service desk and include the following elements:

Determine the target audiences.

Identify their key requirements.

Position services and set appropriate expectations—for example, what requirements will the service desk fulfill, and which requirements will not be offered?

Communicate with customers and their management to identify what they consider to be value from the service desk.

Defining the Customers

It is important to clearly identify and understand customer's requirements. Depending on the size and nature of the customer base, several customers may share the same common needs; however, it is important to understand each customer's unique business requirements. This enables the staff to send individualized messages regarding service desk offerings, resulting in a better experience and increased customer satisfaction. The target market may be divided into the following groups:

Expertise level (novice, average user, expert)

Responsiveness requirements

Hardware, software, or networking systems service needs

Departmental function

Geographic area

Applications used (office productivity, vertical applications, development tools, and server systems)

Identifying the reason for segmenting the customer base, particularly for a high-priority department, is crucial. For example, order entry, which typically requires a 24/7, on-site response, differs from a less time-critical department such as human resources, which may require only 8 A.M. to 5 P.M. telephone-only support.

Understanding Customer Needs

Prior to building the service desk, it is important to understand what the customer might require. This is usually accomplished through research.

There are several approaches to determining this type of information. One approach is to conduct a needs assessment survey with representatives of the target market to learn their immediate, day-to-day concerns. A survey distributed to all potential service desk users can provide a sampling of basic concerns. The survey should ask open-ended questions about the customers greatest day-to-day support challenges. At that time, the service desk planners can outline what the service desk plans to provide and give customer respondents an opportunity to provide their expectations of the service desk.

Another research approach is to interview key users and department heads to identify company trends in support requirements and how these needs may change in the future.

These strategies help build a solid customer-needs information base for use in developing target messages and communication plans. In addition, the strategies provide the basis for setting expectations and managing user perceptions and demands on an ongoing basis. These analyses should be a continual activity in order to maintain up-to-the-minute services for customers.

Positioning the Services

When positioning the service desk, the primary task is to clearly delineate the functions provided by the service desk and match them to customer requirements. Setting appropriate expectations provides knowledge to the users that eventually saves them time.

It might be useful to create a feature/function/benefit worksheet that maps service desk functions to customer requirements. Consider preparing a quick information sheet that describes what services are offered by the service desk, including how to request services, procedures, and forms. It might also be useful to include a section entitled "What the Service Desk Does Not Provide" that prevents customers from wasting their time and effort by directing them to the appropriate department. If possible, include lists of other resources for services not covered by the service desk.

Transmitting information to the Customers

Once the service desk audience has been defined and the service desk responsibilities described, the next step is to determine how to convey the information to customers.

What is the best method for transferring information to customers? There is a variety of ways, depending on who the customers are and their location. The following table has a few suggestions on how to transfer information:

Table 13 Transferring Information

RecipientDescription

Internal personnel

Intranet communiqués

 

E-mail or fax messages

 

Presentations at staff meetings

 

Brown bag luncheons

 

Individual or group orientations for new personnel

External personnel

Electronic mail (e-mail or fax)

 

Fliers or brochures in heavy traffic areas

 

Service desk literature for new employee packages

 

Presentations at high-level meetings

What Information Should Be Transferred

As described in the positioning section, it is important to tell customers just what the service desk can do for them. The following is a list of possible subjects to share with the customer:

The range of products the service desk supports.

The type of assistance provided (phone-only, phone and on-site, e-mail, and so on).

Response time commitments.

How to initiate service requests.

Where to first look for answers before calling.

The telephone number to call and identify what information is required for the call.

Escalation procedures (how to escalate issues that aren't resolved).

Hours of operation (what to do for off-hours emergencies).

Where to go for up-to-the-minute information on:

Systems status.

Service desk status information.

Changes or new additions to service desk offerings (for example, new products, new on-site services, and so on).

In order to publicize the benefits of the service desk, publish information about the successes of the service desk—show employees of the business what the service desk is doing to improve their work life. Demonstrate how the service desk has aided cost savings through reduced support and maintenance costs, improved purchase decisions, better relationships with external suppliers, improved customer satisfaction, and so on.

Describe the areas that require improvements, what has been done, and what future plans are in place.

When to Communicate

It is important to remember that users tend to take service desk services for granted. They do so despite the critical role the service desk plays. Continuing to promote the service desk by educating users about its successes and the services it offers ultimately results in increased user satisfaction.

First of all, whenever a new service desk is started or any services are changed, it is important to immediately advise the users.

Continual communication with users is important, especially in the following two areas:

Regular feedback on a weekly or monthly basis on the profile of incidents is important. This information lets customers know that the service desk is committed to them and helps them be proactive by avoiding known issues, rather than reactive in resolving such issues as training or system redesign.

Telling customers how well the service desk meets its goals (hold-times, customer satisfaction, responsiveness) also helps customers see it as their partner, committed to their success.

The final product need not be an expensive, full-color brochure. A simple desktop publishing program can create a low-cost, eye-catching brochure or flyer to publicize the services and educate the customer base.

Where to Communicate

There are various ways to get information to the customer. Organizations use road shows, printed materials, e-mail, the corporate intranet, company newsletters, and presentations (from formal seminars and workshops down to brown bag luncheons). Publicity material can be provided through posters, mouse mats, screensavers, pens—any type of promotional materials. The most important thing is to make sure it is available to the customer.

Training seminars and classes provide an excellent forum for talking about the service desk and how to most effectively use its resources. The efforts spent educating users contributes to improving their self-sufficiency.

Managing Costs and Cost Recovery

When planning and developing a service desk, it is essential to consider the costs involved and how to charge the costs back to the customer. This section briefly describes high-level recommendations regarding service desks costs. However, additional information on charging for IT services (including the service desk) is described in the financial management SMF guide.

Generally, support organizations such as service desks must quantify and control costs and demonstrate a reasonable return on investment (ROI). Ultimately, the questions to answer are:

Is the service desk saving or generating more money for the company than it costs?

Does the service desk provide the needed level of support for the least amount of investment?

Can some other organization (like an outsourcer) provide some or all of the support as effectively but with lower costs?

In many cases, service desks are in the challenging position of being a cost center. They cost their companies money to operate; however, they are not generating revenue, or if they are generating revenue, it is less than the costs they incur.

It is possible to organize service desks that provide external support so that they produce a profit. Regardless of whether the service desk is a cost or profit center, monitoring and tracking any costs for providing services involves senior management.

Cost Analysis

There are several steps to consider when creating cost analyses for the service desk. The following table lists ways to start an analysis:

Table 14 Cost Analysis

Step NumberTaskComment

1

Isolate specific cost categories associated with operating the service desk.

Organize the categories into logical groups and subgroups. Typically, one can do this by assigning unique department codes to each type of expense.

2

Organize all expenses and assign to appropriate category.

These are usually direct expenses (salaries, benefits, and supplies) generated by the service desk, plus any indirect costs (general business expenses, such as hardware, utilities).

Once the data is secured, start the analysis. To be effective, the information must be presented in a way that makes it easy for the senior managers to understand and use to make decisions. There is a wide variety of ways to analyze data; however, the following two categories are typically used by service desks:

Cost-per-person analysis

Activity-based allocation analysis

The following figure is a sample Cost Estimating Worksheet that might be used by a service desk when starting a cost analysis:

Figure 4: Sample cost estimating worksheet

Figure 4: Sample cost estimating worksheet
See full-sized image.

Cost-per-Person Analysis.

It is prudent to evaluate the cost per person for service desk staffing, since staffing determines the majority of service desk costs. Direct cost per person only includes the people providing service desk support to users and the expenses associated with them, such as salary, benefits, supplies, and so on. This measure helps a company manage per-person expenditures and gives it a baseline for evaluating other, potentially less-expensive, delivery options such as temporary or outsourced staff. Direct cost per person and fully burdened cost per person should be evaluated on a regular basis (either monthly or quarterly) to identify and explain variances.

Fully burdened cost per person includes all the direct costs per person plus the costs for all of the remaining staff and management. Fully burdened cost per person measures the total service desk cost per delivery person and helps identify increases in overhead expenditures. The sample costing estimation worksheet shown above provides an example of a spreadsheet that can be used to organize this information.

Activity-based Allocation Analysis

Activity-based cost allocations associate the cost of providing the service desk services (the activity) with the departments using the resource and/or with the support type being offered. The main objective of activity-based costing is to associate cost with the activity driving it in order to facilitate cost-effective decision making. This type of cost allocation can provide a large amount of valuable costing information; however, depending on the level of detail needed, it can also require a large amount of time and effort to maintain.

The activity-based cost of the service desk can then be allocated to the appropriate departments. Allocation methods (used individually or combined to create a charging method specific to a particular organization) include:

Cost per call, which could vary depending on the type of incident or service. Some examples are:

Desktop services (that is, word processing).

Application.

Installation/upgrade request.

Business service (that is, payroll).

•<