The only thing I would add is the ability to program this to any app that is in focus. So you would link it to the .exe of the program running that you wanted to use it with i.e. Adobe Lightroom, then if I wanted to use it to rate or change the white balance. Lots of potential

Initially, my first impression of the dial is that it is a waste of money. But once I figured you can program keyboard shortcuts for each app, the dial seemed to be work the $99.

test

is slow to respond to use if it's been sitting there unused, so is not a very helpful gadget unless you use it constantly without interruption (if a wireless mouse was this unresponsive you'd never use one)...the battery saving implementation is horribly conceived, and while the fit and finish seem okay (not like plastic junk) the functionality is minimal, even if you are one of the few people who could find a use for it...on top of that it is absurdly overpriced for what it is

I'm already enjoying my Surface Dial but find in-app support for Windows Wheel devices frustratingly limited so far. Since I use quite a few Autodesk products on a daily basis for both business and personal endeavors, and those products tend to focus on design of three-dimensional objects, having those products support the Wheel interface would make orbiting models much easier. There are also many other tasks which are less intuitive using a mouse that would benefit from supporting a Wheel device. However, at the same time, it would be nice to see Microsoft add more ability to customize by providing for application-specific custom tools. For example, I would like to add my own custom tool to the Surface Dial menu for when I'm working in a program which allows me to rotate objects, even though the program may not yet directly support the Surface Dial; if I know how to invoke the command through the keyboard or mouse, I ought to be able to add that command to a custom tool on the Surface Dial which becomes available when the associated program is active. Note that this would be a relatively easy software improvement and does not affect the overall functionality of the hardware. Still, it's a fascinating new way to interact with the computer. I hope to see additional development to support the Surface Dial across the board.

I bought the Surface Dial to use with my Surface Pro for digital drawing and painting. For that purpose, it's fantastic. It feels great to turn and I love the way it clicks for some settings. The bottom is a very grippy rubber that works well on many surfaces including my couch. Since it's wireless and grips well, you have a lot of options for where to place it. For example, one time I drooped my arm over the side of the couch while holding the Dial in my hand, and just pressed it up against the side of the couch any time I wanted to turn it. It was great. I've tried a lot of different options for my off hand when making digital art, including a 25-key gaming keyboard. The combination of button+dial is simple, compact, and versatile and could easily replace the 25-key keyboard in the future. And that's where I have a problem. While the radial menu built in to Windows is already designed in a way that would give the Dial that versatility, the actual customization options are not. You have 7 slots that you can fill in the radial menu, but only one of them can be customized. The rest must come from a very short list of pre-made options such as zoom, volume, brightness, and mouse scrolling. At this point in time, there's almost no software that natively supports the Dial, so you're entirely reliant on that one single customization setting for anything useful that you'd like to do. It's actually pretty ridiculous that Microsoft thought this was acceptable. I can't imagine any other hardware manufacturer limiting their device this way. With actual options for customization, it wouldn't even matter that most software lacks native support. Instead, we're stuck with this really awesome tool that's extremely crippled. Looking at the built-in settings, it seems as if Microsoft wanted to sell a really expensive volume knob rather than something actually useful. Depending on your workflow, this can be worked around with a little bit of effort. I ended up changing the hotkeys in my painting program so that I could change one dropdown in the Windows wheel settings menu and it would switch to a new 'configuration.' This is obviously less than ideal, but at least it allows me to make pretty good use of the Dial despite the shortcomings of the software. This would easily be a 5-star review if the device had even the most minimally acceptable level of customization. Hopefully we get there soon.

I use the dial with a surface book 2. It has a pleasant feel, turns smoothly (with or without haptic feedback) and is great for a few applications. When it works and the software supports it, I find it great to use. However, I have a few issues with it: (1) pairing is slow --- when I first start using it, I often have to click it 3 - 5 times and spend maybe a minute getting it to wake up and connect to my surface book. In contrast, the surface ergonomic keyboard and precision mouse and nearly always instant (1-2 seconds, tops). (2) A lot of apps and software do not really support the surface dial. I can understand this from a developer perspective as probably not many people have one. However, it really limits how broadly useful the dial is. Even many Microsoft apps have limited support turning it into a glorified scroll wheel for most applications.

I love the physical device - well made and had great promise. Microsoft seems to have dropped it. It should be completely configurable - what I do when spinning, clicking, etc. is limited (which is frustrating).

It has great potential. I would love if it had a multitouch touchpad on the top to pan across images in Photoshop or artboards in Adobe XD. This can be a great tool to complement mice.

So much potential with the hardware but it just doesn't do anything worth while on the software side. It would be perfect it could at least scroll on things your mouse pointed to but it just scrolls random sections of programs. It also pretty much can only map keyboard shortcuts. Would be nice to map scrolling horizontal and other functions. I most likely will return it.